Definition
Brown bagging has two distinct meanings. The first and most common is the practice of bringing one’s lunch to work or school in a brown paper bag rather than buying food outside. The second, more historically charged meaning refers to the “brown bag test”: a practice in some African American social organizations and historically black colleges in the 20th century, where individuals were judged by whether their skin was lighter or darker than a brown paper bag. Those lighter than the bag were admitted to elite circles; those darker were excluded. The two meanings are unrelated etymologically but are connected in American cultural memory: the brown paper bag is a humble, everyday object that became a tool of racial hierarchy. In contemporary usage, “brown bagging” most commonly refers to the lunch practice, while the “brown bag test” is discussed as a historical example of colorism.
Why It Matters
Brown bagging matters because it touches on class, race, and labor in American life. The practice of bringing lunch in a brown bag is a marker of working-class and middle-class frugality: the person who brown-bags is saving money, often because they have to. In white-collar culture, brown bagging can signal virtue (financial responsibility) or stigma (inability to afford lunch out). During economic downturns, brown bagging increases; during booms, it declines. The practice also matters environmentally: the disposable brown paper bag is more biodegradable than plastic but still contributes to waste, and the trend toward reusable containers has made “brown bagging” somewhat anachronistic. The brown bag test matters because it reveals the internal hierarchies of race. Colorism—the preference for lighter skin within a racial or ethnic group—has existed across cultures for centuries, but the brown bag test made it literal and visible. The practice was documented at organizations like the Alpha Kappa Alpha sorority, the Links, Inc., and at some historically black colleges. It reflected the legacy of slavery, where lighter-skinned enslaved people (often the children of white enslavers) received preferential treatment, and the broader American preference for whiteness. The test is now universally condemned, but colorism persists in more subtle forms: studies consistently show that lighter-skinned Black Americans have better educational and economic outcomes than darker-skinned Black Americans, even controlling for family background.
Example
The brown bag test was not a universal practice but it was widespread enough to be documented by sociologists like E. Franklin Frazier and Gunnar Myrdal in the mid-20th century. At some HBCUs, the test was used at social events: students held a brown paper bag against their skin, and those darker than the bag were excluded from elite parties and organizations. The test was also used in some churches and social clubs. Lena Horne, the singer and actress, was reportedly excluded from some Black social events because her skin was considered too light, while darker-skinned Black women were excluded for the opposite reason—illustrating the impossibility of the standard. For a contemporary example, the “brown bag” as a symbol of frugality appears in personal finance advice: “brown bag your lunch and save $2,000 a year” is a standard tip. In schools, “brown bag” programs provide free or reduced-price lunches to children from low-income families, with the brown bag serving as a discreet way to distribute food without stigmatizing recipients. In workplace culture, the “brown bag session” or “brown bag lunch” is a meeting held during lunch hour, often for training or discussion, where attendees bring their own food.
Internet Angle
Brown bagging is a subject of internet discourse around personal finance, race, and workplace culture. On Reddit, r/personalfinance, r/Frugal, and r/EatCheapAndHealthy feature threads about brown bagging: meal prep ideas, cost comparisons, and debates about whether brown bagging is worth the effort. On r/BlackPeopleTwitter and r/AskBlackPeople, the brown bag test is discussed as a historical example of colorism, with users sharing family stories and academic sources. On TikTok, #brownbag has millions of views, featuring lunch prep videos, “what I eat for lunch” content, and historical education about the brown bag test. On Twitter/X, “brown bag” appears in workplace commentary: “Another mandatory brown bag session on ‘synergy'” is a typical complaint. The term also appears in discussions of remote work: “Now that I work from home, I’m brown bagging every day without even trying.” The internet has also documented the decline of the physical brown bag: as reusable containers and meal prep culture have replaced paper bags, “brown bagging” has become a nostalgic term, used even when the food is in a glass container. The internet has made brown bagging both more efficient (through meal prep communities) and more complicated (by revealing its racial history).
Related Terms
- Colorism — The discrimination against darker skin within a racial or ethnic group, the broader phenomenon that the brown bag test exemplified
- Meal prep — The practice of preparing meals in advance, the modern evolution of brown bagging
- Paper bag — The humble object at the center of both meanings, a symbol of both frugality and racial hierarchy
- Historically black colleges and universities (HBCUs) — The institutions where the brown bag test was most commonly practiced
- Passing — The practice of presenting oneself as a member of a different racial group, often motivated by the same color hierarchies that the brown bag test enforced
Word count: ~610